surendiran

Indica Vista vs Wagon R

Recommended Posts

buy the vista mjd and i am sure that every month or two you'll be at the service station !!! y dont u buy the swift ???
Have you experienced the same or seen somebody at service station every month with VISTA...ok with previous tata vehicles it may be common but i am talking about vista..

And @Surendrin even if its petrol and between the 2 vista is the one to go for..

I'm not sure if it is a good idea to buy a petrol tata vehicle! you see tata has always given first preference to their diesel variants, always pushed their sales..the re-sale value of a petrol tata vehicle will be pathetic! have you ever come across some one who wanted a second hand tata petrol? buy you will find numerous buyers for santros, wagon rs!

If it is petrol, and within 4.5 lakhs, then it has to be the i10 or the a-star. wagon r is proven, but it is too old now.

if you cannot afford either the i10 or the a-star then you can look at the santro or spark!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well yes Tata's petrol arent that successful except Indica xeta which was..But Vista has Fiat's petrol engine so should be good to drive and between the 2 surely Vista is better..WagonR is simply a crap..

If not between 2, he can surely look at i10, A-star, Spark or a Santro..But WagonR, no its not a car for today when excellent cars a available..WagonR to me is worst car which is doing well in india till date..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well yes Tata's petrol arent that successful except Indica xeta which was..But Vista has Fiat's petrol engine so should be good to drive and between the 2 surely Vista is better..WagonR is simply a crap..

If not between 2' date=' he can surely look at i10, A-star, Spark or a Santro..But WagonR, no its not a car for today when excellent cars a available..WagonR to me is worst car which is doing well in india till date..[/quote']

ok..you cannot call something crap if it is in the top 5 selling cars in india consistently for more than 2-3 years!

also i have never heard a wagon r user complain about the car which cannot be said of say the zen estilo or even the santro! sure it looks bad, like a mini tempo traveller, but i think for a family of 2-3 who want a car without any hassles it makes perfect sense. the boot space is even bigger than that of indica! in the same price range you have the spark, the zen estilo and the indica xeta, why arent they doing such numbers?? GM has been pushing spark so much, spending on full page ads every now and then and yet that cannot get spark in to the top 10! its not only about maruti, ASS etc, but also the fact that the car serves its purpose very much! yeah i would like to see wagon r off the streets and be replaced by the ritz. but this will not happen as ritz is gonna be slotted in between a-star and swift. and maruti needs to have a tall-boy car to compete with santro and the i10 and obvioulsy zen estilio is not doing well enough to replace the wagon r!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well its selling just because of maruti name...There is nothing in the car which is good..Even omni is doing wonders for maruti that doesnt means that its deserving vehicle..See the gearshift of WagonR its like 800 only, just sit at rear seat and see hows the comfort, just try brakes and they arent better than santro/spark/palio, just check the build quality and ride quality, its worst..Its just made of thin metal sheet nothing else..

Ok lets not debate on that because such debates you can find on lot of threads so i am tired of writing same thing again..Just because it sells, you cant say its good car..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

From the discussion one thing is sure that Indica Vista is better than Wagon R

Though Quadrajet is diesel version but if we have to compare petrol engines as Wagon R is petrol car even than  Vista Sapphire is better than Wagan R ,One thing here I want to ask if we have to compare now Vista Sapphire Aura with Indogo CS GLX then which car is better  to buy as there is slight price difference between the Two though two are different category cars.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
From the discussion one thing is sure that Indica Vista is better than Wagon R

Though Quadrajet is diesel version but if we have to compare petrol engines as Wagon R is petrol car even than  Vista Sapphire is better than Wagan R ' date='One thing here I want to ask if we have to compare now Vista Sapphire Aura with Indogo CS GLX then which car is better  to buy as there is slight price difference between the Two though two are different category cars.
[/quote']

 

Surely the Vista sapphire should be better than the Indigo CS Petrol. But i really don't rely on the Petrol car of the Tata. If petrol cars are compared then i would really prefer the i10. A fantastic car even though costlier than the Vista sapphire and Indigo CS Petrol, its worth paying.And the Accent GLX is also worth mentioning. Its a Hyundai Car with a good Engine and reasonable features and good comfort. The price of the Accent Glx is really attractive. Its somewhere available around 5 Lakhs.
rki20072009-03-13 16:44:17

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Vista is way too advanced than WAGON R.

Space , comfort, power, style , look, everything is offered at a 4-5 lacs .

bracket.

Wagon R is selling not only because of maruti name , it is built on most Popular WAGON Platform , seating, and Better Visibility in city roads. Wagon R accomodate ever a taller person.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 For surendiran it is better to buy Vista in comparison to Wagon R as per suggestions but As Wagon R is now old car we should compare VISTA with Swift and i-10.Then it will be better comparison or A star may be included if price factor is also to be considered.  so friends I am creating new thread to compare these cars please give your valuable comments.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi all experts,

 

Thank you all.

I had decided to go for Vista.

I will be keeping the vehicle for 5-7 yrs. 

 

Intially i will be driving less, and later i will be driving more .

 

Can i go for Vista TDI as vista quadrajet will be out of my budget.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

surendiran, tdi engine is the older gen engine from tata, i would suggest you to book quadrajet base model, its refined multijet from fiat,gens ahead then its tdi engine, i can guarantee you wont regret your extra amount spend on quadrajet.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@ surendiram : As tv said quadrajet is obviously worth the extra bucks and you can go for the base model.

Since you will keep the car for 5-7 years, quadrajet will be more reliable too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi forum members,

thanks for all your views.

I had bought Indica Vista Quadrajet Aura on april 8 2009.

Till now i had faced any problem. Not yet taken Long trip.

 

The suspension is very good in Vista , like a sedan.

Very spacious.......

Less noisy.....

Light streeing...

nice gear shifts...

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Congratulations Surendrian on the right choice made! Enjoy your ride. For the instructions on running in the car, check the owner's manual supplied along with your car!

Do post some pictures of the car!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now