My take on the mags available:
Overdrive (8/10): Improved a lot since a certain someone left. Good focus on Indian motorsport, the best amongst any others, and for that alone, they should be lauded. However, their road tests and the presentation of them leave a lot to be desired. I really don;t like the format they use.
Top Gear (4/10): Really dont see the point of this magazine. If you look at it as a cheaper way to get the original TG articles, then fine, but as a source for anything Indian, it is rubbish.
Car India (6/10): I like the photography in this. Very slickly done. But again, I am not a fan of a few key people running the show, and the way they present themselves in the magazine. Its a good mag for reading while waiting at the Doctors clinic or airport.
BS Motoring (6/10): A bit lost really. No serious testing done (" 0-100 in ABOUT 12 seconds" !!!), but just seems like a bunch of enthusiasts having a good time, which comes across in their writing. nice light reading. I personally like the driving/riding impressions of imports in India.
Auto India (1/10): Not sure if anyone actually buys this anymore. And rightly so. nuff said.
Autocar (9/10): No, not sucking up coz of the forum, but it is genuinely the best out there right now. Sharp writing, good technical details, good test format, good mix of international and national coverage. Indian motorsport coverage needs to be improved a lot though, and so does the focus on 2 wheelers.