unknownbullet

Compare VISTA with SWIFT,I-10,A-STAR

Recommended Posts

Friends Please give your comments  for VISTA ,SWIFT, i - 10 and A-star

Which car is no. 1 which is no. 2 ,3,4 as per your opinion .The  criteria is

Fuel efficiency , Comfort , Maintenece,Engine quality ,Resale Value,Boot space ,price etc.some other features which you feel are worth mentioned.

And one thing we have to compare only petrol cars don't include diesel versions in comparison.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Swift is good in almost all aspects but it's not that comfortable.

If you consider i10 kappa, the only flaw is that it's a little pricey.

Vista has better quality than previous Indica's and it has lots of space.

I don't like A-star much, it has good ride and handling though and FE is slightly more than i10 but doesn't look good(atleast to me), rear seat is too cramped and boot space is limited too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Friends Please give your comments  for VISTA ' date='SWIFT, i - 10 and A-star

Which car is no. 1 which is no. 2 ,3,4 as per your opinion .The  criteria is

Fuel efficiency , Comfort , Maintenece,Engine quality ,Resale Value,Boot space ,price etc.some other features which you feel are worth mentioned.

And one thing we have to compare only petrol cars don't include diesel versions in comparison.
[/quote']

As per your criteria...

Vista - No 1 ( mileage, space, price)

i10 kappa- No 2 ( engine quality, comfort)

A-star - No 3 (Fuel efficiency, driving comfort, Maintenance)

Swift(performance, maintenance)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

RESALE value & tata these are two sides of magnet......... No VFM No FE High MNTNC Cost , this is what tata cars stand for...... first year u will find it loving but once u start visiting service stations u will see how expensive it is.......

rating wise

1. swift VDI

2. Hyundai i20

3 hyundai i10

4. swift VXI

5. a star coz only milege but no space

6. vista

 

if u wana to invest in VFM then i say for diesel go with swift & if u like petrol then try hyundai i20 or i10

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
if performance is concerned' date=' i20 loses out to swift, but ride, braking, space, cabin aand a 225 page long list of specs, you might just think twice[/quote']

 can u please provide 225 pages cons list to auto car forum users  .... u  mentioned in ur response .......

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

if performance is concerned' date=' i20 loses out to swift, but ride, braking, space, cabin aand a 225 page long list of specs, you might just think twice[/quote']

?can u please provide 225 pages cons list?to auto car forum users? .... u? mentioned in ur response .......

Ahum!

OOPS!

Actually i wanted 2 type 2.5

looks like a typo smiley2.gifsmiley36.gif

but still it has a longer list of specs than any other hatchback!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

PETROL

 

1. i-10 sportz

2. Swift Vxi

3. A-star Zxi

4. Vista with fiat engine

 

Diesel

 

1. Swift VDI

2. Vista with fiat engine

 

For fuel efficiency , Comfort , Maintenece,Engine quality ,Resale Value,Boot space ,price and latest features

 

1. i-20 Asta

2. Swift Zxi

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I seriously wonder why people underestimate the value of the Indica Vista. Some rank it so terribly. I doubt, If they have even had a look at the real car.

When I test drove the Vista, it felt like driving those SUV type cars. Huge stance, clear view of the road, and undettered by those big bumps and pot holes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Friends I want to compare these cars not only for buying purpose but analytically also that why for particular reason one car is good and the other is bad ,so try try to elaborate your views instead of just writing go for i-10 or go for vista etc ,Friends please specify what are the pro & cons of perticular car.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

swift is my no 1 choice for its looks, decent vfm and a great driver's car. it also has a fantastic driver's seating position.the only draw back is the rear seat, which is not all that cramped compared to i10, but the rear windows are small, so that sort of creates a cramped feeling.

i10 comes second coz it has pretty good interiors has very versatile variants, 2 engine options, automatic etc. h/ever i dont feel great in the driver's seat and the car does not look radical.

a-star has to be third coz of the space that it offers. but the interiors look good, it reminds me of the old zen!

vista comes 4th and last not because it lacks features, but the fact that tatas have always given importance to their diesel variants and they never promote their petrol variants in a big way..so you may even enjoy the car better than the above three, but when you sell you will lose a lot more! the re-sale value of petrol tata cars are pathetic and will remain so forever until tata gives equal push to both.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If its a diesel I would rate Swift above Vista. Both have the same engine and not so good build quality and Vista scores over Swift in the size department but Swift scores in a more peace of mind ownership experience, looks(vista is not that bad but cant beat the swift espescially in white). So if rear space is not a big concern (swift is adequate) I think its Swift in the diesel.

If its a petrol I would say its Swift, i10=Vista, A-star. Everybody who talks about comparing Swift and i10 just talks about not so good build quality of Swift. I agree that Swift does not have a very good build quality, it rattles, but these are thing you can get used to. You cant just sit in a car for 15 minutes and say that the rattling is unbearable. When it comes to i10 and Vista, i10 scores in build quality and A.S.S. alone. Both have very good engines but Vista comes up is the very big difference in space (atleast you feel so). I had once went shopping with my friends in an i10 and it was difficult to seat 3 abreast at rear. Not such a big problem in Vista. So again if space is not your concern go for i10 over Vista. A-star is last because of shockingly less space. It has good interiors and has the best fuel efficency of the four but this much lack of space will concern anybody except those without any family to carry. The boot is adequate only for shopping trips and not highway trips. No rear space, no boot space Maruti has done some magic here by vanishing all the space. Also the oddball design doesnt inspire me much.

So these are my personal opinions about these cars

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Tata Motors Indica Vista Aura Safire
Price(Jaipur): Rs 3,86,833/-

Maruti Suzuki Swift LXi
Price(Jaipur): Rs 4,07,232/-

Change

Change

 

 

 

 Color

 Gala Red, Artic Silver, Solar Orange, Marine Silver, Cavern Grey, Infinity Black, Noble Blue

 Metallic Iridium Gold, Metallic Ozone Blue, Metallic Sunlight Copper, Pearl Metallic Arctic White, Metallic Azure Grey, Metallic Midnight Black, Metallic Silky Silver, Solid Bright Red

 Fuel Type

 Petrol

 Petrol

 Expert Rating

           

           

 

 Features:

  Accessories

  Air Conditioning

   

   

  Power Steering

   

   

  Leather Seats

   

   

  Sound System

   

   

  Body Coloured Bumpers

   

   

  Rear Defogger

   

   

  RearWash Wipe

   

   

  Wheels (Std./ Alloy)

   (Standard)

   (Standard)

  Sunroof/ Moonroof

   

   

  Automation

  Power Windows

   

   

  Adjustable Steering

   

   

  Dimensions

  Ground Clearance (mm)

 165

 170

 

  Trunk Volume (lt)

 280

 232

 

  Dimensions LWH (mm)

 3795*1695*1550

 3695*1690*1530

 

  Wheelbase (mm)

 2470

 2390

 

  Tyre Size

 175/70 R13

 165/80/ R14

 

  Performance

 

  Engine Displ. (cc)

 1172

 1298

 

  Number of Gears

 6

 5

 

  Transmission

 Manual

 Manual

 

  Fuel Type

 Petrol

 Petrol

 

  Drive Type

 FWD

 FWD

 

  Economy City (KpL)

 10(Claimed)

 11 (Claimed)

 

  Economy Highway (KpL)

 13(claimed)

 16 (Claimed)

 

  Top Speed (KpH)

 145(claimed)

 174 (Claimed)

 

  Number of Cylinders

 4

 4

 

  Power (Bhp)

 65.00

 87.00

 

  Torque (KgM)

 9.60

 11.00

 

  Kerb Weight (Kg)

 1075

 980

 

  Safety

 

  Central Locking

   

   

 

  Rear Seat Belts

   (3)

   (3)

 

  Fog Lamps

   

   

 

  Anti-lock Braking Sys.

   

   

 

  Number of Airbags

   

   (N )

 

 

intable_leftcurve.gif-->

 

intable_btmrtcurve.gif-->

 

>

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Tata Motors Indica Vista Aqua Safire
Price(Jaipur): Rs 3,62,469/-

Hyundai i10 Sportz 1.2 Kappa
Price(Jaipur): Rs 4,31,015/-

Maruti Suzuki Swift VXi
Price(Jaipur): Rs 4,37,834/-

 

 

 

 

 Color

 Gala Red, Artic Silver, Solar Orange, Marine Silver, Cavern Grey, Infinity Black, Noble Blue

 Electric Red, Alpine Blue, Oyster Grey, Crystal White, Sleek Silver, Stone Black, Deep Ocean Blue, Blushing Red

 Metallic Iridium Gold, Metallic Ozone Blue, Metallic Sunlight Copper, Pearl Metallic Arctic White, Metallic Azure Grey, Metallic Midnight Black, Metallic Silky Silver, Solid Bright Red

 Fuel Type

 Petrol

 Petrol

 Petrol

 Expert Rating

  

  

  

 

 Features:

  Accessories

  Air Conditioning

 y

y

y

  Power Steering

 y

y

y

  Leather Seats

   

   

   

  Sound System

   

y

   

  Body Coloured Bumpers

 y

y

 y

  Rear Defogger

 y

y

   

  Rear Wash Wipe

   

   

   

  Wheels (Std./ Alloy)

y

y

y

  Sunroof/ Moonroof

   

   

   

  Automation

  Power Windows

y

y

 y

  Adjustable Steering

y

y

   

  Dimensions

  Ground Clearance (mm)

 165

 165

 170

  Trunk Volume (lt)

 280

 225

 232

  Dimensions LWH (mm)

 3795*1695*1550

 3565*1595*1550

 3695*1690*1530

  Wheelbase (mm)

 2470

 2380

 2390

  Tyre Size

 175/70 R13

 155/80/ R13

 165/80/ R14

  Performance

  Engine Displ. (cc)

 1172

 1197

 1298

  Number of Gears

 6

 5

 5

  Transmission

 Manual

 Manual

 Manual

  Fuel Type

 Petrol

 Petrol

 Petrol

  Drive Type

 FWD

 FWD

 FWD

  Economy City (KpL)

 10(Claimed)

 12( Claimed)

 11 (Claimed)

  Economy Highway (KpL)

 13(claimed)

 16(Claimed)

 16 (Claimed)

  Top Speed (KpH)

 145(claimed)

 155(Claimed)

 174 (Claimed)

  Number of Cylinders

 4

 4

 4

  Power (Bhp)

 65.00

 80.00

 87.00

  Torque (KgM)

 9.60

 11.10

 11.00

  Kerb Weight (Kg)

 1075

 860

 1000

  Safety

  Central Locking

y

y

y

  Rear Seat Belts

y

y

y

  Fog Lamps

 y

   

   

  Anti-lock Braking Sys.

   

   

   

  Number of Airbags

   

y

y

unknownbullet2009-03-21 01:50:12

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...